Here’s how much homework I did before this show: none. Zero. My girlfriend said, “Hey, I wanna go check this out,” and I said yeah, sure, something to do on a Sunday. I didn’t read the description or look up a single thing.
In my head, this was going to be a bunch of people standing on stage doing Alanis Morissette songs. Somebody belts out “Ironic,” somebody does “Hand in My Pocket,” everybody claps, we go home.
That’s not it at all.
So what the hell did I just watch?
Jagged Little Pill: The Musical uses Alanis’s songs to tell a completely original story. Nobody plays Alanis, and it doesn’t walk through her career. Diablo Cody wrote it, the same Diablo Cody who won an Oscar for Juno, and the music comes from Morissette and Glen Ballard, the guy who co-wrote the original album with her back in 1995.
The story is about the Healys, a family in suburban Connecticut that looks perfect on paper. The mom sends out the happy Christmas letter every year. The dad works constantly. The son just got into Harvard. The adopted daughter is done with everybody’s polite pretending. Then the whole thing cracks open: opioid addiction, sexual assault, adoption, identity, a marriage barely hanging on.
Going in blind, that was a brain twist. You’re sitting there expecting a sing-along, and twenty minutes in you’re watching a family fall apart to songs you’ve known since high school. I was seventeen when that album came out. I did not expect “You Oughta Know” to land on me like that thirty-one years later.
It isn’t some community-theatre fluke, either. The show got fifteen Tony nominations, more than anything else that season, won two of them, and the cast album won a Grammy.
Wait, some of these people had never done this before?
The Chippewa Valley Theatre Guild put this on in the Jamf Theatre at the Pablo Center, and we caught the very last performance on Sunday. CVTG is a volunteer community theatre that’s been around since 1981. The cast was a mix of local veterans and people stepping on stage for the first time.
When I found that out afterward, my reaction was holy shit. These are people with day jobs who rehearsed at night, then got up on the biggest stage in town and sang about addiction and assault in front of their neighbors. They pulled it off. It was really, really good.
We got booted, and it was the best thing that happened all day
The wheelchair seating in that theatre is down on the floor, so we’d have been right on top of the stage. Before the show, staff came over and said, basically, we need to move you, because we need that space to bring set pieces in and out.
They weren’t kidding. They used every entrance in that theatre. Set pieces came in from everywhere and moved all over the room the whole show.
So they moved us up to the mezzanine, and honestly, it was a better seat. From up there you could see everything: the staging, the movement, how they built each scene. And for the inconvenience of moving us, they gave us drink tickets. So I got a better view and free drinks out of the deal. I’ll take that kind of inconvenience any day.
The verdict
I walked in expecting a cover band and walked out impressed. CVTG didn’t pick an easy, safe show. They picked a raw, heavy, PG-13 musical and nailed it with a local cast.
If they do something this bold again, I’m going, and this time I might even read the description first.

I was part of the cast in this show. This article is a HUGE compliment. Thank you so much for coming & we at CVTG can’t wait to hear what show you attend next.