I’ve been doing IT long enough to know how this ends. It’s always DNS. And if it’s not DNS, it’s a guy named Kevin who tripped over a power cord on his way to the vending machine, and now half the eastern seaboard can’t open a PDF. Occam’s razor: the simplest explanation is usually the right one, and the simplest explanation for almost every disaster in the history of computers is that somebody did something stupid.
I know that. I believe that. I’m putting it right here at the top so nobody screenshots this post and sends it to their uncle.
But I’ve also seen Live Free or Die Hard more times than is healthy, and this week has been weird enough that I need to talk it out. So grab your tinfoil — the heavy-duty stuff, not the store brand — and let’s go.
Let’s Review the Fire Sale Checklist
For those of you who didn’t spend 2007 watching Bruce Willis launch a cop car into a helicopter: a fire sale is a three-stage cyberattack. Stage one, take out transportation. Stage two, telecommunications and finance. Stage three, utilities. Everything must go.
Now look at the calendar.
Tuesday, Apple goes down. Thursday, Microsoft. Friday, the FAA grounds every departing flight in the country. Sunday, a rocket full of Amazon internet satellites goes poof. Monday, online banking hiccups and United’s systems take a dump. Tuesday, the NSA — the actual NSA — loses its own classified network.
That’s a checklist with things crossed off.
First, They Came for the Cat Pictures
Every good villain knows you soften up the population before you go for the big stuff. You don’t start with air traffic control. You start with people’s photos.
Last Tuesday night Apple sign-in just stopped working. iCloud, Mail, Calendar, Photos, Game Center: gone. Some people got signed right out of their own devices. It lasted about two hours, which in iPhone time is roughly the length of the Dark Ages.
Nobody riots over air traffic control. Take away somebody’s cat pictures for two hours, though, and you’ve got a population that will accept anything. Rationing? Sure. Martial law? Fine, just give me back the picture of the dog in the Halloween costume.
And then — I swear I’m not making this up — Apple announced that its Support Community forums, the place you go to ask strangers why your Apple thing is broken, are shutting down for good on November 20th. They broke everything and then took away the place where you complain about it. Somewhere a Bond villain is taking notes.
Thursday, Microsoft finishes the job. Outlook, Teams, Copilot, all down worldwide. So if you’re an iPhone person, you couldn’t email anybody, and if you’re a Windows person, you couldn’t email anybody either, which means nobody could send the “is yours down too?” email. Total communications blackout. Textbook.
Microsoft’s own report says the bug behind it was introduced back in July. It sat there for four months like a sleeper agent. A sleeper agent that passed load testing.
And you know who the real victims are? Guys like me, getting the “can you fix my iCloud” calls Tuesday night and the “can you fix my Outlook” calls Thursday morning. Nobody’s making a movie about us. Nobody launches a cop car into a helicopter for the IT guy.
Windows 95 at 35,000 Feet
Friday afternoon the FAA grounded every departure in the country. More than twelve thousand flights got canceled that day.
What happened? A router — contractor error or bad equipment, take your pick — started flooding the rest of the air traffic control network with over a thousand connection attempts every four or five seconds. The old system got overloaded and fell over. No hackers required. It’s the network equivalent of your aunt hitting reply-all on the church newsletter.
Then the Transportation Secretary got up in front of reporters and said, on the record, “We use 1980s little copper lines.”
Little copper lines. That is the official explanation from the United States government. I have better cabling in my apartment. I have better cabling in a junk drawer.
Here’s the thing: last year we all found out the FAA was still running parts of the system on Windows 95 and floppy disks. Floppy disks. The thing the save icon is a picture of. Their plan was to modernize it while it’s running, 24/7, because you can’t exactly turn the sky off for a weekend. This outage landed right in the middle of that multibillion-dollar rebuild.
You don’t swap the engine on a car doing 70 down I-94. You especially don’t do it with no plan, and from out here it sure looks like there’s no plan. I can’t get a small business to run their Windows updates. These people are migrating air traffic control live.
The Agency That Reads Your Mail Couldn’t Read Its Own
And then this Tuesday. NSANet — the classified internal network the National Security Agency uses to share secret stuff — went down. They had to stagger when people showed up for work at Fort Meade. The official explanation: “routine maintenance.”
Routine maintenance. The people who can read your texts, your email and probably your grocery list couldn’t get into their own intranet. Somewhere a guy with top-secret clearance was standing in a parking lot refreshing his phone like the rest of us.
To be fair, it was a partial failure, and they say the mission-critical stuff kept running. But this is the same agency that in 2013 had a contractor walk out of a classified facility with a mountain of stuff he wasn’t supposed to have. I’ve said before that a lot of it should’ve been public anyway, and I got yelled at on social media for it, so we’re not doing that again today.
But it tells you one of two things. Either they were “doing updates” back then too, or “routine maintenance” is just government for “Kevin tripped over the cord again.”
Or Maybe It’s a Test
Theory number two, and honestly I like it better: maybe nobody’s attacking us. Maybe the government is just running a stress test to see how much shit the American people can take.
Somewhere there’s a windowless room with a guy holding a clipboard. Day one, no photos: “Subjects still scrolling.” Day three, no email: “Subjects still scrolling.” Day four, no airplanes: “Subjects yelling at gate agents, then scrolling.” Day seven, no bank: “Subjects mildly annoyed. Still scrolling.”
The results are in. We can take all of it. That’s the scary part. They could turn off the sky and we’d just post about it.
Occam’s Razor Wins (And That’s Worse)
OK, tinfoil off. Here’s what I actually believe.
Nobody’s running a fire sale. Nobody’s measuring us. Every one of these outages has an explanation — a bad update, a bad router, an old system, a maintenance window that went sideways — and nobody has pinned any of it on an attack.
And that’s scarier than the movie. In the movie there’s a bad guy, Bruce Willis shoots him, and the lights come back on. In real life there’s no bad guy. There’s thirty years of “we’ll fix it next budget cycle,” a pile of floppy disks and some little copper lines, all coming due the same week.
There’s nobody to shoot. There’s just a bill.
Anyway, stage three of a fire sale is utilities, so if you need me, I’ll be filling the bathtub and staring at my power company’s status page. My lights flickered about an hour ago. Probably nothing.
Probably Kevin.
