Back in the early 90s there were a couple shows on 101.5 WIBA FM. This is way before Rolling With Scissors was even a dream.

 It was definitely before iHeartRadio took over the freaking world.

 The two shows I’m talking about were called Rock Line this program has been gone for a long time, but there are actually quite a few episodes available on YouTube.

 There is also a show on after that call Desert Island Disc. These were both interview shows with various artists. 

Desert Island Discs would ask each artist if they were stuck on a desert island what are the five albums they would want with them. The show was originally created on BBC Radio 4. When they brought it over to the United States, the format changed a little bit.

Being that we’ve been on the air for nearly 30 years at this point, I thought I would rework this post which was originally published back in like 2003.

I’m gonna change the rules a little bit. I’m going to say what 20 albums would you want on a desert island with you?

I am also reaching out directly to people in the music industry could be artists, producers and people we may get some interesting set lists from.

I know there are people that are going to ask. It doesn’t matter if the album is a double disc or not it does not count against your 20 album limit. 

Comments are turned on at the bottom of this post. Let’s come up with some great set list together.

My list in no particular order. I numbered them in the list just to make it easier to keep track.

1. Tool Aenima

2. Fleetwood Mac Rumors

3. Dream Theater Awake

4. Alan Parsons Project Eye In The Sky

5. Stevie Wonder Talking Book

6. Grateful Dead,American Beauty

7. The Beatles White Album

8. Eagles The Long Run

9. Pat Metheny Group The Road To You

10. Woodstock Original Soundtrack

11.Pearl Jam Ten

12. Nirvana Bleach

13. Jim Croce Classic Hits

14. Tom Petty & The Heartbreakers Damn The Torpedoes

15. .Nine Inch Nails Pretty Hate Machine

16. The Gits Seafish Louisville

17. Alice In Chains Jar of Flies

18. Rush 2112

19.  Michael Franti & Spearhead Stay Human

20. James Taylor Greatest Hits

I will admit this is a difficult task. There may have to be an honorable mentions update in the future. I hope you all get as much joy out of this exercise as I did.

Due to the crap, we all have to deal with on the Internet, also known as spam. After you post your comment you will not see it until it’s approved.

12 Comments

  1. Josh Hollar

    Black Sabbath – Black Sabbath
    Black Sabbath – Heaven and Hell
    Black Sabbath – Born Again
    Dog Fashion Disco – Anarchists of Good Taste
    Polkadot Cadaver- Sex Offender
    Knives Out! – Black Mass Hysteria
    Major Parkinson – Blackbox
    Twelve Foot Ninja – Outlier
    Landon Tewers – Dynamite
    Various Artists – Loud Rocks
    Johnny Cash – American IV
    Nine Inch Nails – With Teeth
    Poor Man’s Poison – Providence
    Hank III – Straight to Hell
    Gojira – From Mars to Sirius
    Godhead- 2000 Years of Human Error
    Marilyn Manson – Mechanical Animals
    Samurai Pizza Cats – You’re Hellcome
    Tony Iommi- Fused
    Tony Iommi – Iommi

    Reply
  2. Lucas Prince of Darkness

    see it works just like that. Josh has some amazing suggestions that now that I see them. Of course they would be on the list. If the list was longer, lol

    Reply
  3. Emu

    Dog fashion disco – adultery Tom waits- raindogs
    Ween- chocolate and cheese
    Primus- sailing the seas of cheese
    Frank zappa- over-nite sensation
    Clutch- the elephant riders Tool-aenima
    Barry white- the ultimate collection
    Buckethead- the deli creeps
    Morphine- cure for pain
    Mr. Bungle- California
    Ill mitch- still mitch
    Marvin gaye- number 1’s
    Pantera- vulgar display of power
    Faith no more- angel dust
    Miles davis- on the corner
    Mr. Gnome deliver this creature
    Murder by death- in bocca al lupo
    Pink floyd- animals
    Bone thugs n Harmony- creepin on ahh come up

    Reply
  4. Dave Watts

    O’Jays – Traveling at the Speed of Thought

    Short Stuff – Short Stuff

    Culture – Two Sevens Clash

    Black Sabbath – Black Sabbath

    Donna Summer – Four Seasons of Love

    James Cotton 100% Cotton

    James Carr – The Complete Goldwax Singles

    Koko Taylor – The Earthshaker

    Marvin Gaye – What’s Going On

    Herbie Mann – Memphis Underground

    Earl Van Dyke – The Earl Of Funk

    The Notorious B.I.G. – Ready To Die

    B.B. King – Live at Cook County Jail

    Tammy Wynette – The Best Of Tammy Wynette

    Clarence Carter – The Fame Singles Volume 1 1966-70

    Muddy Waters – The Complete Aristocrat & Chess Singles A’s & B’s 1947-62

    Miles Davis – Jack Johnson

    Jimmy Smith – Christmas Cookin’

    Nat King Cole – The Nat King Cole Christmas Album

    Beach Boys – Pet Sounds

    Reply
  5. Rick Tvedt

    See, if you go with the live albums you cover more territory.

    1 Captain Beyond
    2 Yes Yessongs
    3 Chicago IV
    4 Grand Funk E Pluribus Funk
    5 Mahavishnu Orchestra Inner Mounting Flame
    6 Porcupine Tree Deadwing
    7 Chris Squire Fish Out of Water
    8 Camel A Live Album
    9 Yes Going for the One
    10 Yes Tales From Topographic Oceans
    11 Ralph Towner Solstice
    12 Jane Siberry The Walking
    13 Terje Rypdal Whenever I Seem to be Far Away
    14 Hawkwind Space Ritual
    15 Yes Relayer
    16 Genesis Seconds Out
    17 Steve Winwood s/t
    18 Steven Wilson The Raven That Refused to Sing
    19 George Harrison The Concert for Bangla Desh
    20 Peter Gabriel Secret World (Can I take the DVD too?)
    Also, why can’t I take a hundred?

    Reply
  6. Thump

    I’m curious how we’re going to be listening to these, and 20 ain’t nearly enough – Rick gets it.

    A somewhat random selection out of many possibilities:

    1. Guns N Roses: Appetite For Destruction
    2. Tom Waits: The Heart Of Saturday Night
    3. The Beatles: 20 Greatest Hits
    4. Metallica: Ride The Lightning
    5. Miles Davis: Kind of Blue
    6. Nine Inch Nails: The Downward Spiral
    7. N.W.A: Straight Outta Compton
    8. Run DMC: Raising Hell
    9. Beastie Boys: License To Ill
    10. Living Colour: Stain
    11.Vangelis: Blade Runner Score
    12. John Williams: A New Hope Score
    13. Pyotor Tchaikovsky: The Sleeping Beauty Ballet
    14. Ministry: Psalm 69
    15. Pantera: Cowboys From Hell
    16. Band Of Gypsies: Band Of Gypsies
    17. Black Sabbath: Paranoid
    18. Kenny Burrell: ‘Round Midnight
    19. Ted Greene: Solo Guitar
    20. Prince and the Revolution: Purple Rain

    Reply
  7. The Reverend

    Alice In Chains – Dirt
    Animals As Leaders – The Madness of Many
    Depeche Mode – Ultra
    Dream Theater – Scenes From a Memory
    Lana Del Rey – Ultraviolence
    Leonard Cohen – The Future
    Loreena McKennitt – The Book Of Secrets
    Melissa Auf Der Maur – Out Of Our Minds
    Metallica – Death Magnetic
    Meshuggah – Immutable
    Nightwish – The Greatest Show On Earth
    Nine Inch Nails – The Fragile
    Orbital – In Sides
    Red Hot Chili Peppers – Stadium Arcadium
    System Of A Down – Toxicity
    Tangerine Dream – Quantum Gate
    They Might Be Giants – Flood
    Tool – Aenima
    VAST – Visual Audio Sensory Theater
    Zella Day – Kicker

    Reply
  8. Gary Osmond

    Oz
    Good god this is hard to do. I had to cut so much great music just to make it to 20.
    You will probably figure out that I’m older than dirt , just look at my choices. I noticed that after about 1990 my selections did drop off
    In no known order it goes like this

    The Grateful Dead (of course) Workingmans Dead

    James Taylor Hourglass

    The Beatles. Rubber Soul

    George Harrison. All things must pass

    Santana. Abraxas

    Neil Young. After the gold rush

    Herbie Hancock. Head hunter

    The Beach Boys. Pet Sounds

    Miles Davies. On the corner

    Paul Simon Graceland

    Marvin Gaye. What’s goin on

    Stevie Wonder. Songs in the key of life

    The Rolling Stones. Exile on Main Street

    Sly and the family Stone. There’s a riot going on

    Tom Petty. Full moon fever

    Bruce Springsteen. Born to run

    Traveling Wilburys. Volum 1

    Bob Marley. Legends

    50 cent. Get rich or die trying

    Reply
  9. Matt Mommaerts

    Emerson, Lake & Palmer
    Welcome Back My Friends to the Show That Never Ends – Ladies and Gentlemen
    Using a double live album loophole to get material from Tarkus and Brain Salad Surgery.

    Dream Theater
    Live Scenes from New York
    Another loophole here… this includes live version of all of Scenes from A Memory and A Change of Seasons

    Nevermore
    Dead Heart In a Dead World
    Perfect!

    Opeth
    Deliverance
    tough to pick between this and Blackwater Park.

    Death Angel – Act III
    Flotsam and Jetsam – “Cuatro”
    Powermad – “Absolute Power”
    These three were early in my metal listening years, and got a lot of plays…

    Rush – Moving Pictures
    Or I might exploit the live album loophole again and go with Exit… Stage Left.

    Soilwork
    Natural Born Chaos
    Really cemented my love for this band

    Incubus – “S.C.I.E.N.C.E.”

    Winery Dogs – Self titled (1st album)
    Three albums to pick from, I guess I’ll just pick the first here.

    Neal Morse Band – Innocence & Danger
    Tough to pick one from these guys too… I’ll pick their most recent effort, epic, emotive and top prog rock/metal-ish stuff.

    Transatlantic – The Final Flight: Live At L’Olympia
    So much great stuff from them, I’ll elect my live album loophole here again.

    Yes – 90125
    This one got a lot of plays in early high school as I transitioned from pop music to rock/prog.

    Lords of the Trident – The Offering
    Local band and friends… they get better with every release, Shadows from the Past is also excellent

    Luna Mortis – The Absence
    Also a local band, but perfect balance of catchy melodic metal with death metal aggression too.

    At The Gates – Slaughter Of The Soul

    Liquid Tension Experiment – LTE 2
    Yeah a lot of Mike Portnoy bands on this list, go figure.

    Wilco – What’s Your 20?: Essential Tracks 1994–2014
    I’ll use the greatest hits loophole on this one 🙂

    Queensryche – Operation Mindcrime

    Reply
  10. Tom

    Stone Temple Pilots – Core
    Tool – Lateralus
    Nirvana – Incesticide
    Au4 – And Down Goes the Sky…
    Pink Floyd – The Wall
    The Very Best of Buddy Holly and the Crickets
    The Beatles – Abbey Road
    Tool – Fear Inoculum
    The Police – Zenyatta Mondatta
    NIN – The Downward Spiral
    Midnight Oil – Diesel and Dust
    Extreme – III Sides to Every Story
    Daft Punk – Random Access Memories
    Bjork – Post
    Yes – Fragile
    Ben Folds – The Unauthorized Biography of Reinhold Messner
    Blues Traveler – Live from the Fall
    Helmet – Betty
    Paul Simon – Graceland
    Bauhaus – The Sky’s Gone Out

    Reply
  11. The Almighty Ruler of The Universe

    In no particular order…
    Stone Roses – Stone Roses
    Rolling Stones – Exile on Main Street
    Prince – Purple Rain
    Led Zeppelin – Physical Graffiti
    Tool – 10,000 Days
    Porcupine Tree – Lightbulb Sun
    Miles Davis – Ascenseur pour l’echafaud
    Maggie’s Dream – Maggie’s Dream
    Bob Marley & The Wailers – Exodus
    Bujinin – Glossolalia
    Cake – Fashion Nugget
    Fleetwood Mac – Tusk
    The Clash – London Calling
    Pink Floyd – Wish You Were Here
    Dead Milkmen – Beelzebubba
    Black Sabbath – Paranoid
    Gillian Welch – Revival
    AC/DC – Back In Black
    Hugo Kant – Secret Society
    Tom Petty Wild – Flowers

    Reply
  12. Millennial Angst

    In no order:

    1. Losing Streak – Less Than Jake
    2. Love Supreme – John Coltrane
    3. Jews with Horns – Klezmatics
    4. – Green Day
    5. Midnight Marauders – Tribe Called Quest
    6. The Food Album – MF Doom
    7. The Real McCoy – Joe Henderson
    8. The Shape of Jazz to Come – Ornette Coleman
    9. Spiritual Unity – Albert Ayer
    10. The Bridge – Sonny Rollins
    11. Sonny meets Hawk – Sonny Rollins
    12. Blues and the Abstract Truth – Oliver Nelson
    13. The Kennedy Project – Oliver Nelson
    14. Blue Serge – Serge Chaloff
    15. Birth of the Cool – Miles Davis
    16. Bad Hair Day – Weird Al
    17. The TV Album – Weird Al
    18. New York Mary – New York Mary
    19. Lee Morgan – Live in Baltimore
    20. Clifford Brown – Study in Brown

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

DON'T MISS AN UPDATE
Subscribe To Rolling with scissors